Thread:Wazzirving/@comment-61371-20120303161509/@comment-2051886-20120310005126

Let me start-off by saying that I dislike written conversations over physical, because of all of the misunderstandings. I also see the core of what you are trying to say. I still disagree that the Age of X characters from the 616 reality, Bishop's Age of Apocalypse, or anything similar to those scenarios deserves a page. Age of X does not have a number. It was numbered on this site, by fans, as "To Remain Numbered". I think that we should mention the changes to the character that were affected on their pages. The Avengers from that world and the entire rest of the Age of Apocalypse cast are exceptions, because they belong to those realities, but not the characters in question.

About my "...because a character goes to another place, has a different name, and changes their personality, then they deserve a page dedicated to their brief moment of difference" comment, you either don't reread the previous edits, or there is a nice sized misunderstanding, because I was just telling him that if those earlier mentioned members of Age of X and Bishop in Age of Apocalypse get a separate page, then Rachel should. I also said that it "... doesn't exactly fit as a uniform idea, because, then, we should make a new page for every character that was brainwashed or under the influence of magic..."

I conceded my argument when you posted "And until Rachel returned, we WOULD and DID treat Mother Askani AS Rachel. Yes, she may be revealed to a new character in the future..." and "When we know better, then we can make the changes (creating a separate Mother Askani page. A page for the Mockingbird Skrull), but until then, there should be a FIRM reasoning for it being a separate page, not just "it's happened before" ". I don't think that is exactly the SOP of our site, but if that is how you want it operated, then I understand. If we operate by that reasoning, I can also see why you don't see a correlation between any of the scenarios that I presented. Let the page merge and I'll clean-up all of the changes I made.

On a side-note between us, I feel that you handled this all the way to the left (not the right way). I asked you at the very beginning "Tell me why considering her a separate character, like Mother Askani, isn't needed" and that was all you really had to say, but you wished to play a different card that left us roughly a weeks worth of useless debate. You first had me under the impression that the reason you changed it was because you didn't think it was "discussed" then went from useless point A to at lest G. Just tell me the rules, or how you feel the wikia should be ran during your term as an admin, and I'll agree.