Board Thread:Policies/@comment-16461120-20170313235242/@comment-10473115-20170417184914

After the recent discussions about the flaws of our decision-making, I read the thread again to see if there's a voting that we should start because discussion didn't resulted a consensus. I deemed myself to being too involved in the issue for suggesting a voting but collected all arguments for different options. There were also lot of interesting debate about which characters should be categorized as hybrids, what appearances should be listed at all, and what are justifications for an own page. I disregarded all those to get back to the original purpose of the thread: How to list hybrid appearances?

* / Hybrid
 * - "False" appearances

* Elder God/Asgardian Hybrid
 * + Direct link to the hybrid category

*
 * Preferred option by every one if the race article is justified and created


 * If the article is not created
 * - Possibly redundant categorization, appearances of "Human-Spartoi"="Peter Quill"
 * - Dozens of sparsely-populated categories
 * - Categories would be too general and diverse
 * - An appearances category not tied to a page is hard to find
 * - Increases category clutter
 * + Categorization helps research
 * + Appearances of some hybrids groups could be worth of categorizing even without an own page
 * + No "false" appearances

It's unfortunate that we couldn't reach a consensus through a discussion but I hope that this list helps to put out a voting, if better evaluation of consensus is needed.