Thread:ADour/@comment-398454-20121128214105/@comment-398454-20121128221420

I have respect for the contributors to the Alternate Universe Master List; several of them are personal friends. However, that said, that list is not canon, although its likely accurate in the vast majority of instances.

As for it being "most obvious" that AEMH takes place before the other, its hardly obvious. The odds of AEMH being chronologically before W&tXM is, at best, specious and doubtful, as it was written afterwards. Can you cite one bit of precedent that indicates that AEMH takes place prior to the mainline timeline of W&tXM (obviously the future sequences are, but as may be)? Or does it have to be that way because you stubbornly refuse to accept it as proof that the two do not share a universe.

But as may be. I am appealing your decision with an admin; I believe you to be mistaken, and unreasonably unwilling to accept official, canon information that contradicts the contention, which was originally solely based on Yost's intention, as stated in a prior interview.

BTW, Joshua Fine should be co-credited with the creation of AEMH.