Thread:The Many-Angled One/@comment-25192437-20160922014854/@comment-25192437-20160922021515

The Many-Angled One wrote: Arawn 999 wrote: The Many-Angled One wrote: I think the way to go would be renaming Klyntar to Klyntar (Race) and then move Planet of the Symbiotes (Location) to Klyntar (Planet) (we don't put reality designations in location pages), with Klyntar serving as a disambiguation page.

And what about the symbiotes that aren't "Klyntar", like the ones from Earth-1610? Or the ones that are extraterrestrial but have origin stories that differ from those of the mainstream Klyntar, like the ones from Earth X or Spider-Man 3? What do you mean? My point is that the only symbiotes that have been called "Klyntar" are the ones from Earth-616, and a handful of others that are assumed to, inferred to, or confirmed to share their exact origins.

The symbiotes from Earth-X are extraterrestrial, but they are a metaphysical life form created by the Celestials - whether that's also the case for Earth-616's Klyntar is unknown.

In contrast, the symbiotes of Earth-1610 are (or rather were, given the Ultimate Universe's destruction) an artificial protoplasmic lifeform created by Richard Parker and Edward Brock Sr., with no relation whatsoever to Earth-616's extraterrestial origins. And that's not getting into the symbiotes that are supernatural in nature. Lumping them all under Earth-616's rename of "Klyntar" isn't completely accurate.