Thread:AnnabellRice/@comment-25192437-20191104065923

HBK123 and I are debating whether it is speculation to list any other incarnations of Gwen Stacy aside from the one from Earth-617 as being members of the Council of Spider-Women.

My argument is that in, Charlotte Morales-Stacy tells Utaa and Utau that all super-powered incarnations of Gwen Stacy - including her mother - are members of the Council of Spider-Women, and that the organization routinely meets at her mother's house.

HBK's counterargument is that the Council is only namedropped once - after Charlotte makes that statement - and that all she's saying there is that other incarnations of Gwen visit the house, with no mention being made to the Council.

I was wondering if you and some other moderators and admins might be willing to weigh in on your interpretation of that scene and provide input in hopes of reaching a consensus on the matter. Our debate can be found https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Thread:1348132 