User blog comment:Realmartialarts/Know your sources/@comment-4890977-20120919185954/@comment-2198188-20120919231556

Actually in the same crossover, a villain downloaded all of Batman's fighting skills and fought Captain America, who at the time did not have his shield. So it was completely based on skills. In the end, Cap won easily. Though it there is factor of that villain probably is not in the same shape that Batman is.