Thread:ADour/@comment-29259794-20131115012636/@comment-2054358-20131207143200

Yeah, we are arguing over authorial intent. Odin was never seen dying in the movie, LoveWaffle misinterpreted an interview again. And when a an event is not seen in-universe, writers can easily retcon it without a plothole. And LoveWaffle has been refusing to watch it when I explained it, relying on distorted memory and thinking he's seen it enough times. If he really did rewatch it, he should find his error. Anyway, I'm going to remove Odin's deathdate and the ApDeath because there is no real proof that Odin's dead. LoveWaffle, before undoing my edits, watch the video again. You really have to. Don't rely on memory. Really analyze the video as much as I did. Taylor was answering a question about Loki when he said "took us a while to realize we're actually going to kill him." In the context of the movie, it actually makes more sense for Loki than Odin because Loki was the one stabbed in battle by Kurse and had the emotional death scene, and then came back at the end in Odin's throne. It was very unclear what he did with Odin. He could have thrown him in the dungeon. The only person who mentioned Odin dying in the interview is Hopkins who used the words "Maybe" and "Dunno", which are words of uncertainty. And I don't think we should take the words of an actor who was clearly unsure into account.