User blog comment:Deadpool fan11/Who Would Win?/@comment-1538701-20111222183220/@comment-3317214-20111223025343

Or, perhaps if we make a full cycle with this science talk, because Gamma radiation doesn't actually make you more buff (or even give you an insanely buff, green alter-ego), but instead, gives you radiation sickness and increases your chance of getting cancer, the Hulk shouldn't exist. And I doubt that any type of "jump" in evolution (which is unlikely in itself) would result in such a variety of abilities in the one species (particularly if most of these abilities are scientifically ridiculous- creating ice with your mind, teleporting, etc). So, with mutants not existing, Wolverine wouldn't have his powers, and so either would have died if people tried to coat his bones in some impossibly strong alloy, or they wouldn't have done it in the first place. So assuming that they didn't try to coat his bones in metal, given that Wolverine learned martial arts and stuff, I'd say he'd win in a fight with a skinny scientist. However, without his healing factor, Wolverine's probably aged, and he's about 50 years older? So, that shifts the odds in Banner's favour. But on the other hand, if the Gamma explosion still happened, Banner would probably be dead. So, Wolverine wins.