Thread:Shabook/@comment-10473115-20160327104119/@comment-10473115-20160328194142

I checked few Asgardians's pages and saw that most pages which are using title in alias field, were changed by you and few other editors just a month or two ago. So that's hardly any site wide consensus and those edits should be reverted also. Alias is still another name, not real name. Peter Parker don't have aliases Peter and Parker although we use nicknames on alias field because we don't have a better choice at the moment.

I agree wholeheartedly with you that we should have more guidelines how to fill template fields, especially on infobox. Popular characters's infoboxes have become so cluttered with trivial information that they are unreadable. Problem is, as you know, that finding consensus about that, would probably be very hard to achieve here. Few editors would tell how they are filling the fields and others would be quiet as seen in this thread. Without guidelines, we edit articles back and forth and most persistent editors will win. Of course that's one way to achieve some kind of consensus, but not very productive.