Board Thread:Policies/@comment-16461120-20170313235242/@comment-10473115-20170317095036

Shabook wrote: That's was the previous consensus. I still don't understand why was it changed with a formal discussion and community agreement. That consensus was achieved between some editors and we don't have any site-wide policy or guide about it. Also, consensus could be challenged at any time as has happened now. I understood that Annabell started this discussion because different styles have already been used widely and it would help us to get some consistency.

Like already explained, Fu Manchu moustache example don't really help us here because it's a unique "item" like individual hybrid is an individual character. But we are talking about appearances of a group, like Human–Kree -hybrids or Moustaches. Also, nobody has even hinted to ban all race appearances. It came to discussion only from straw man which Shabook constructed so there's no point continuing about that subject.

LoveWaffle wrote: You would also need to propose that page and the other categories it is tied to should go with it. Sorry for OT comment, but I want to disagree with this. Categorization and an article page should be considered separately although our use of page templates often ties it together. That's a problem we should find different solutions (page without template, modifying template, etc.) I tried to start a discussion about categorization of suit appearances without much as a result. As the problem is worse than I knew, with even moustache appearance categorized, and there seems to be shared worry about it, we should try to tackle it at some time.