Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1713281-20130314165720/@comment-4651179-20130316000207

"Nah, I'd wager that the Bucky page would just feature realities where Bucky where James Barnes is DEPICTED as Bucky. The way you have to think about it is divorcing the real name under the costume."

I think none of the disambig pages are meant to be the disambig of the name, as it is the disambig of the civil identity as well. That was one of the main reasons I did those edits in Archangel's page: If someone is looking for certain alternate Archangel, they'll have a link to a page where there's a full list of alternate Warren Worthingtons, not just of those were he was Archangel.

And it would be pretty much a mess. Maybe you're looking for certain alternate reality Steve Rogers, but wait! I'm looking for an alternate reality where he's Nomad, so it won't appear in Captain America's page and will appear in Nomad's page. It's not a good way to split the information.

What would happen with some characters who in their alternate reality versions they have some uncommon alias? Like Peter Parker being Poison in certain What If..? number. Where will it appear? Because as you suggest, it shouldn't appear in Spider-Man.