Thread:ADour/@comment-26991858-20151008135844/@comment-3406131-20151008205731

Sorry, but please do an effort in English. I'm not trying to mock you, I myself had trouble to learn, and I still do many mistakes in English, but here it's really painful to read you.

CountAbyss77 wrote: -ej:a person seeks to know the character and whether it is bad to good to read the comics where it appears as the wiki is not in that list is idiot no have the list It would be a list of stuff who aren't always true, regarding your perspective. The Punisher is good, bad and neutral. Doom is, Cyclops also, Xavier, Wolverine, Iron Man. Each of them can be classified as the three, or as none.

Choosing to read comics regarding the alignment that someone choose subjectively for a character doesn't seem to be a really good logic.

CountAbyss77 wrote: -if I read comics, but not all, and then a character that I know I will not know if it's good or bad that you had the bright idea to delete just being subjective Well you can base your own judgment on what you've read. And you will change it or not, regarding the following issue, if you happen to read it...

CountAbyss77 wrote: -official basis????see friend although not official should be a list dividing good and evil then each have their own opinion but I feel good now must be order this wiki does not serve me ast does not serve me as before and now do not know if the character is good or bad and can not have an opinion about something I do not know People can have directly their own opinions. Read the comics, or read the page (which is written in a neutral perspective, and make your judgment based on your own perspective).

The sole (or the main) purpose of this wikia for you was to have the alignment ? That's sad given the massive compilation of material here.

CountAbyss77 wrote: -I do not mind the power of the character is interesting but not his character alignment give a shit Watch you language and here an example where I don't understand you, I'm not sure if you're aggressively sarcastic, clearly aggressive, or just aggressively interrogative.

CountAbyss77 wrote: -at is subjective does not mean it is not important in fact is one of the things I liked about the wiki since the characters could know then I think if it was good or bad It's not that isn't important, it's it doesn't have any sense (cf. the links I gave you in my previous answer, AnnabellRice's answer is pretty complete).

CountAbyss77 wrote: -you care more if the species is good or bad no sense what you say and the species or power is added to the lineup is more basic character is bad or all good and that you have to differentiate no matter what you say A species isn't good or bad, I never said I cared about such a thing.

And no, we don't "have to differentiate no matter what [I] say", because it is an information that is too subjective to be worth a spot here, given its characteristic.

I will sum up:
 * Alignments are unofficial except on a few cases of handbooks (who are allowed here under some conditions of form)
 * Alignments can go from good to bad given the lecture you have of a character. Consequently:
 * They are a subject of edit wars, without any people being right or wrong
 * They don't have sense if they can't be fixed at least at some point. Wolverine is a mutant, an X-Man, an Avenger. That's defined stuff. But ask people what alignment he is, you will have at least three answers (if we restrict the answers to alignments). I would myself give the three answers, given the different aspects of his personality and his actions. Therefore, it is useless.
 * Alignments are oversimplistic, especially in the world of Marvel who isn't (or wasn't that since many years or decades already) defined by heroes vs. villains, bad vs. evil opposition anymore: Heroes are killers and manipulators, villains redeem themselves.
 * Neutral was mostly a catch-up category for redeemed villains and borderline/anti-hero, and any ambiguous character.
 * Instead of filling the page to allow readers to make their own choices, many editors lazily filled the alignment field and nothing else instead.