Board Thread:Policies/@comment-10473115-20160314013421/@comment-26066818-20170414220203

There definitely has to be some leeway for the rules, especially the second one. Ignoring all other considerations for this example, I wouldn't say make a Giant-Man's Suit appearances category just because it's seen draped over a chair in the Wasp's bedroom in an issue Hank Pym doesn't appear. On the other hand Porcupine's Suit, which appeared regularly on its own in the Avengers Trophy Room, would deserve tracking.

But since "Items" or "Suits" is such a broad category, whether we use my suggested rules or other ones, they'll have to be flexible. "Guidelines" instead of actual rules, like the pirates say. That's part of why I was trying to nail down the Goal people had in mind for including Suit pages. And what's the best way break them down? "Ant-Man's Suit" would include suits worn by multiple men of one Identity but not all the suits they've worn, vs. "Hank Pym's Suit" would include all the suits worn by one man but not all the suits worn by those Identities. Which is preferable? By what standard?

Knowing the Goal for what information we're trying to preserve on the Wiki would help us articulate better how to accomplish it.