Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24715049-20150215223811/@comment-26130483-20150221004257

Personally, go with her first appearance as Cindy Moon. In the first issue of her series, she explains how she became Silk. The Silk in her first issue is not as capable as Silk in The Amazing Spider-man issues or in The Edge story arc, so getting the first appearance of Silk would make her character feel inconsistent. Also, she is set on getting back who she was--Cindy Moon with parents and little brother who love her, so, since being Cindy Moon is that important to her, I would go with that appearance. But I don't collect books for value, so I could be entirely off-base.