Thread:Shabook/@comment-3406131-20171204081420/@comment-3406131-20171204182216

I'm not sure what you mean for all parts of your answers so I will answer it part by part (sorry), don't hesitate to correct the possible errors:

Shabook wrote: Main reason i started is, besides there are many characters whose species is absent from the article, is that the Asgardians are a mess. The Asgardians are a mess, yes, and the "Asgardians were aliens of Earth-9997" doesn't exist (the person who added the material didn't created the page and I haven't yet gone through it to create it. But mixing stuff won't help.

Shabook wrote: The category Asgardians is for the Asgardian citizens, not members of the Asgardian race. Yes. I recently added the category "Asgardia Gods" to distinguish both meaning, but haven't yet created "Asgard(ian) citizens" (I was actually unsure if I should do it, but from what I understand, we should".

Shabook wrote: If an origin is explained with the usual formula of Name of the race article in singular no category appears. It has to be coded into the module. I just did.

Shabook wrote: Then there is the Aesir, but also the category Asgardian Gods, which I feel are basically duplicates. But adding the Asgardian tag also adds a bunch of categories such as Deities, Virtual Immortals. Aesir and Asgardians are often used as duplicates, but not always: Cutting down to one thing without expanding the page doesn't help (I'm still collecting a few references to do it).
 * Aesir and Vanir are sometimes presented as two tribes of the Asgardians, or the blend of the two makes the Asgardians.
 * There's also the fact that there are other gods. It is unclear what kind of god they are ("Asgardians" or another stuff).

"Deities" are currently added to all deities pages (Akua, Jumala, etc.). Same here. I'm still unsure on if they should appears as individuals on that category. On demons, I've created "hidden categories" accessible from the categories to list to be sure that all demons are listed, no matter their race.

For the "virtual immortals", it's a power accessible to all Asgardian gods as far as we know (another thing I must try to check on possible exceptions).

Shabook wrote: I was just doing what I felt was right, or at least the most widespread option so that there is some sort of consistency and categories are as inclusive as possible. I felt there is some lack of consistency on the subject, between being inclusive and being relevant.