Thread:Ben 1,000,911/@comment-37854037-20191117063838/@comment-24812000-20191117204336

Actually, I have read that issue. Have you? Because even though it seems like it, 616 Peter never met Mayday prior to Spider-Verse. Let me explain: In Spider-Girl #10 and 11, Mayday goes back to the past of Earth-982. Even though much of 982's past is like 616's past, there are differences. For instance, Aunt May died for real in that past, whereas in 616, her death was faked. Also, even though they may seem very similar, Peter from 982's past and Peter from 616's past are different simply because those are alternate universes. Maybe they had similar histories, but they are physically different people. It is said in Spider-Girl #10 and 11 that they are in the past of Earth-982, not 616, so 616 Peter had never met Mayday prior to Spider-Verse, since that was the first time she visited 616.

If you want to argue that she DID go into the past of 616, here's another story element I can tell you about: Peter meets Mayday as a civilian and as Spider-Girl separately. Spider-Girl at the very end reveals that she is his daughter, but never says that her name is Mayday. Peter does meet Mayday as a civilian also, but he never learns that Mayday is Spider-Girl. In Amazing Spider-Man v3 #9, the first part of Spider-Verse, Spider-Girl unmasks herself to Peter and says "We've met before. You know me," to which Peter responds, "Mayday?" implying that they are more familiar with each other (and her origins) than her quick reveal at the end of Spider-Girl #11.

This is a rare example of a writer making a mistake. They aren't perfect, but Dan Slott made a mistake here. Dan Slott made it so they met another time, but that story still needs to be written now.

Also dude, stop with the religious stuff on character pages. What's that even about?