Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-61022-20160330220251/@comment-24812000-20160406105117

Undoniel wrote: Ben 1,000,911 wrote: Okay I'm mostly arguing the Ultimate End thing, but for the Invisible Woman bit: I believe there was a part in Secret Wars where Doom said that he found Sue from a dimension where Reed Richards never existed. That's why I'm arguing that the Handbook was wrong in that respect, and another respect where earlier in this thread someone said there was an official statement saying that the handbook was wrong. I don't recall it, but that quite possible he said something like this. And lied. Doom's Secret Wars favorite hobby was lying. To be searched and documented. The "official statement" was presumably Brevoort's ? (who seems to have been grumpy and inconsistent in his Secret Wars related answers)

Ben 1,000,911 wrote: And what do you mean I want it to be them? I don't want anything. This is a controversial comics event that will be resolved no matter what I or any of you want. So I don't want anything because we will eventually have an answer I hope. I just believe that the characters ARE them.

Level with me here, even though it may sound a little unprofessional: this is a comic book. Right? This mini-series has the same people that the common reader is used to in the regular comic titles. Though they may all be different characters with the exact same personalities and histories when their memories are restored and etc, that is unlikely. Why? The common reader will not think of that. Because the writer did not explain that in a prologue or later story or anything. So it is assumed that this is all one and the same by the common reader, and should be. It is very elaborate to make alternate counterparts of the 616 and 1610 characters in this way. And I mean Secret Wars is elaborate to an extent, but not in the theory that the same people were created again as alternate counterparts and then all killed off ruining the point of the mini-series. Even if the characters don't remember Secret Wars, they would not ALL die after confronting Doom. The 1610 ones would, but the 616 ones would later live to tell the tale. Does this make any sense to you Nausiated? It makes sense in my head and I'm not always the best at explaining things I'm thinking about. The fact it involves your belief, "coincidences", that it is "elaborate", that no one told us before the handbook isn't an uncommon thing. But again: until there is an official correction, the handbook is the answer, nothing more to search, maybe precision on how this mess is done (That one reality/two realities/two domains stuff still bothers me). Okay YOU make the most sense out of anyone here. Alright I concede again until there is proof like an official correction.