Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-5788640-20121217175949

Hum... Hi... New here... I just realized that maybe I just put my foot in it... There wasn't really anything in the "Talk" section of the first dozen or so articles that I edited, so after some time, I just didn't pay it any mind anymore. So I edited the disambiguation pages of Phoenix/Jean Grey/Marvel Girl/Rachel Summers/Phoenix Force, without noticing that there was some sort of huge debate about the Phoenix entries. But I made a neutral choice in my editions, so I hope it won't cause any trouble. It just was confusing to have two disambiguation pages per character for both Jean Grey/Phoenix and Rachel Summers/Marvel Girl. Besides there was a lot of alternate versions of Jean Grey which were in the Jean Grey's page but not in the Phoenix's page, and two or three were in the Phoenix's pages and not in the Jean Grey's page. And likewise for Marvel Girl/Rachel Summers. So I just found it a little more clear to have Jean Grey as the disambiguation page for this character and Rachel Summers for that one. I put all the alternate versions of each character in those pages, but aside from that, those pages are still the same as before. There also is very few changes to the Phoenix Force disambiguation page. I just put the Phoenix Five Team there. The main changes are in the Phoenix and Marvel Girl disambiguation pages.

The Phoenix disambiguation page is now like this: - The description that already was there, is still there. - Entries for the disambiguation pages of Jean Grey, Rachel Summers, Hope Summers, Madelyne Pryor and Phoenix Force. (It didn't seem necessary to put every and each minor Phoenix Host there, since the Phoenix Force disambiguation page already contains all the other Phoenix Hosts entries.) - Entries for Helmut Zemo (Earth-616) (who called himself Phoenix at one time) and Phoenix in Arizona.

The Marvel Girl disambiguation page is now like this: - The description that already was there, is still there. - Entries for the disambiguation pages of Jean Grey and Rachel Summers. - Entries for the articles of Candace Southern (Earth-616), Valeria Richards (Earth-9809) and Dream Summers-Richards (Earth-9891). - Entry for Marble Girl (Earth-9047) page.

I hope that these changes won't cause any problem, but I think they make it a little more clear, without arbitrarily deciding who is the "real" or the main Phoenix host. But if there is any problem, I will put everything back like it was before, myself. ^^' 