Thread:Monolith616/@comment-3406131-20151214202106/@comment-3406131-20151215154513

Monolith616 wrote: With Frey/Freyr, I think it comes down to whether we're assuming more by saying they're the same guy, or saying they're different guys. Njord founded the Vanir according to Marvel, and Frey and Freyja are typically siblings. So it could be that "Freyr" is another name for Njord. I would have thought it was the same character, but mainly due to the idea that Freyr and Odin seemed as old, both grandsons of Buri. But that nothing of a proof.

To sum up, we have the following characters: Idunn/Freya, Freya, Freyja/Frigga, Frey/Freyr,

Monolith616 wrote: Ve Borson and Vili Borson would also need Pre-Ragnarok splits. Maybe we'll have to first add the different known Ragnarök to the page. Do you think separate pages would be better than sections on page ? Given "we" (as readers) have seen a Ragnarok, and the pages cover both the Pre and post-last Ragnarok.

Monolith616 wrote:There's a family tree in, but I've lost my copy. At least some of the info is found in the issue link above. Apart from giving the name of Vidar's mother and confirming the Frigga-Odin sons, it doesn't bring much.

The trick with Amora and Idunn is how quickly the information crossed paths. In Ages of Thunder #1 (June 2008), Amora was stated to be an incarnation of Idunn in a past life. In A-Z #4 (Sept 2008), Amora's only Relative was Lorelei. In the Mythologica (Sept 2009), Bragi is an ex-husband. In the A-Z #14 (June 2010), it's back to Bragi - Idunn, with no mention of Amora. Any OHOTMU reference for Asgardians later than that? In, Idunn is one of the sole characters whose mini-entry doesn't state anything: "Goddess". She could be Asgardian by default, but most of the others (except for Tyr) are stated to be "Vanir", "of Asgard" or "Asgardian".

I would go to ask on Cxpulp, but the last questions I have asked about hanbooks inconsistencies have been left unanswered.