Board Thread:Policies/@comment-10473115-20140601144724/@comment-10473115-20150719193735

NYPD members already have an own list which definitely should be linked from NYC residents list. We can assume that they mostly live there. We also have a huge Manhattan/Residents -list and lots of from other parts of NYC. I think that those could be linked together easiest using categories. But that could be decided later when we know what to do with these lists and pages.

I agree that a distinction between current and former residents/members don't sound very relevant when speaking these characters and it would be enough to just mention it on the text, lumping them to a common list. However, characters with an own page arranged to the separate lists could be helpful, although I don't have a strong opinion about that. What I think is that we really should separate these minor characters to own lists and treat them differently than the others.

I want to clarify my attitude a little towards this question. I really think that everything and I mean everything in the Marvel Universe deserves to be documented here. But how and where is the question. If we want to document every character who is named in 75 years, we have to find a better solution. I really want to help in designing that but I'm little frustrated what happened earlier. I created the subpages for the longest lists and as far as I know, nobody else hasn't created a one. So if there's nobody to move the content, thinking about it is a moot point. Then it just comes down to a question, do we keep or delete it?