All of them are basically the same in power levels. There’s no reason to believe the spider bite in one universe would make Peter stronger than a Spider Bite from another universe.
People will say Tobey’s the strongest Spider-Man because of the “Train Scene”. Okay? Tom also held a ferry together and lifted half of a building off of him, and Andrew was able to fend off Lizard underwater despite Lizard’s obvious insane strength levels, not to mention the advantage Lizard had underwater.
People will say Tobey’s the most resilient Spider-Man because he survived the beat down Sandman gave him while Venom held him in place. So? Tom got hit by a fucking train THREE times in his career and he’s not even 20, and Andrew took the full force of Electro’s power while holding his webs together in the exact position necessary.
All 3 Spider-Man at equally agile too. Just because Tobey’s beefier than the other two doesn’t mean he wasn’t able to quickly dodge Goblin’s razor bats and Doc Ock’s speedy tentacle attacks. Andrew skipped around a power plant using his webs in super creative ways while an angry energy monster chased him and destroyed the environment around him. Tom had to be quick with the placements of his web gadgets when keeping the ferry together, likewise with Mysterio’s drones, and he too quickly dodged the ruthless attacks of Doc Ock while he was making his way towards an endangered civilian.
All 3 Spideys are incredibly intelligent. Tobey is a huge nerd, Andrew created his web shooters in a garage and developed the formula for the Lizard Serum and Cure, and Tom also created his own web formula and learned how to use his super advanced techno-suit and web features in 45 minutes, oh, and he invented a cure for Doc Ock’s insanity.
Point is, these Spidermen are very different but they are still the same character. If the three got into a fight none of them would win because they all have the exact same strengths and weaknesses.
