Horace Rosenthal met Matthew Murdock in college and taught him that everyone deserved the best efforts they could give, defendant as well as plaintiff. Years later, Detective Stan Carter came to him in the middle of the night to receive a warrant after the murder of his partner, but found the judge with a prostitute.[1]

Later, he released on their own recognisance the street gang members who assaulted Ernie Popchik and were defended by Matt Murdock. As soon as he left the court, he was attacked and shot by the Sin-Eater.[2]

Hit in the chest by a shotgun, he died immediately.[3]


None, human.

Discover and Discuss


Like this? Let us know!

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.