Appearing in "Shadow Selves"
- Mina Hess
- Detective Brigid O'Reilly (Main story and flashback)
- Francis Xavier Delgado (Main story and flashback)
- Mayhem (Main story and flashback) (Origin revealed)
- Officer Bradford (Only appearance; dies) (Only in flashback)
- Uptown Block Kings (Main story and flashback)
- Roxxon Corporation
- "That Which Stands at the Crossroads" (First appearance) (Unnamed) (Impersonates Officer Fuchs)
- James Connors (Photo) (First name revealed)
- Billy Johnson (Photo)
- Terrors (Mentioned)
- Ben Urich (Mentioned)
- Dale (First appearance) (Main story and flashback)
- New Orleans PD (Only in flashback)
- Sergeant Paulson (Only in flashback)
- Officer Wyatt (Only in flashback)
- Chief Duchamp (Only in flashback)
- Parish Board
- Reed (First appearance) (Only in flashback)
- Douglass (First appearance) (Only in flashback)
- Adina Johnson (Only in flashback)
- State Senator Asa Henderson (First appearance) (Only in flashback)
- Connors' uncle (Mentioned)
- Edwin Dunlap (Only in flashback) (Death)
- Money Hustle Gang (Only in flashback)
- Brett Latour (Only in flashback) (Death)
Synopsis for "Shadow Selves"
Tandy, Tyrone, and O'Reilly go to Mina Hess for answers after escaping from O'Reilly's doppelgänger. Based on her own experiments, Mina has discovered exposure to the chemical from the Roxxon leak can split an individual into two different people alike in every way except that one is docile and the other aggressive (and much stronger), although she's never seen it happen in a human before. The three of them follow O'Reilly's own instincts to find her duplicate's apartment and evidence of her own investigations inside. In the months since the Roxxon leak, the aggressive O'Reilly - dubbed "Mayhem" - looked for Detective Connors on her own, but ran into a dead end with his former partner. She became bloodthirsty after impulsively killing Connors' partner, and started investigating the sex trafficking ring to satisfy her bloodlust. Her investigation into the ring brought her to the meeting between the Uptown Block Kings and Money Hustle Gang where she killed everyone.
Tandy, Tyrone, and O'Reilly find Mayhem attacking someone connected to the sex trafficking ring at a strip club. She gets away when O'Reilly can't bring herself to shoot her doppelgänger. They follow her to a truck yard, where she has already rescued a number of girls by killing one of the ring's drivers. Tyrone looks into one of the girls' fears to find a building the sex traffickers operate out of. Tandy and Tyrone get there before the aggressive O'Reilly, and Tyrone wants to do something before she can hurt any more people. Tandy generates another ball of light to blind everyone inside the building so Tyrone can go in and rescue the girls being held there. Tandy gets held up by two gang members waiting outside the building, only to be saved by Mayhem's timely arrival. Mayhem grabs one of their guns, goes inside, and starts shooting everyone. Tyrone pulls her inside his cloak to stop her. Mayhem, now in a dark dimension, finds a refrigerator with Officer Fuchs' dead body stuffed inside. Fuchs asks her if she's up for "awkward reunion pancakes."
- Delgado is revealed to have quit his job at Tyrone's school and his alcoholism relapsed.
- O'Reilly's learned her method of using playing cards to keep notes from an old reporter in New York, referencing Ben Urich from from the Netflix series Marvel's Daredevil.
- No trivia.
|Dagger / Tandy Bowen||Olivia Holt|
|Cloak / Tyrone Johnson||Aubrey Joseph|
|Melissa Bowen||Andrea Roth|
|Adina Johnson||Gloria Reuben|
|Det. Brigid O'Reilly|
|Francis Delgado||Jaime Zevallos|
|Mina Hess||Ally Maki|
|Officer Fuchs||Lane Miller|
|Solomon||Joshua J. Williams|
|Chief Duchamp||Andrea Frankle|
|Edwin Dunlap||Jon Eyez|
|Brett Latour||Scott Allen Perry|
|Sgt. Paulson||Lenita Harris|
|Officer Wyatt||Breon Pugh|
|State Senator Asa Henderosn||John Fertitta|
|Board Member 1||Eleanor Threatt|
|Board Member Douglass||Oliver Thomas|
|Board Member Reed||Kim Baptiste|
|Officer Bradford||Tim Bell|
|Gang member 1||Christopher Ambrose|
|Gang member 2||Artrial Clark|
|Young woman||Betsy Borrego|